Example report · fictional answers
Financial services platform modernisation
An exceptionally large, tightly-coupled change meeting an organisation with weak capacity with a constrained evidence loop.
- Change loadExtreme
- CouplingHigh
- Execution capacityWeak
- Evidence loopConstrained
Why this execution state
Coupling is high, and coupling at this level has no counterbalance: capacity can absorb load, but nothing absorbs coupling; it can only be constrained. The change load is extreme and the capacity available to absorb it is under strain. Execution capacity is weak. The evidence loop is constrained: the organisation is slow to validate assumptions or act on what it learns. On this many fronts at once, the demands of the change and the organisation's ability to meet them are materially out of balance.
Strategic risk: the shape of the transformation
These readings come from your answers about the scale and structure of the change itself: what is being attempted, not how it is going.
The marker shows where each reading sits on the scale from low to very high risk. For Execution Capacity and the Evidence Loop, weaker sits further right.
Why this reading
Based on your answers about the breadth, depth, concurrency and pace of the changeWhy this reading
Based on your answers about how interdependent the changing parts areWhy this reading
Based on the people, organisation and delivery mechanisms; scope size is excluded because it measures exposure, not capacity; reduced one step because you reported heavy competing day-to-day workload on the people delivering the changeWhy this reading
Based on your answers about how far the culture inhibits collaboration, challenge, experimentation and transparency (Defensive Culture, H1)Why this reading
Effective only when neither Validation Lag (D4) nor Strategic Response Lag (D5) reaches Material concernThe model relationship, populated with this assessment's readings: capacity absorbs load; nothing absorbs coupling; a defensive culture multiplies the whole relationship; the evidence loop governs how quickly the organisation learns and responds.
Where risk is concentrated
Mechanisms grouped by dimension and concern band. Select a mechanism to see what it means.
Operational risk
How the transformation is running
These 17 mechanisms describe conditions inside the transformation today. They constrain the structural reading; they do not replace it.
Each dimension shows the band shared by most of its mechanisms, so a single outlier does not speak for the whole dimension.
Human
6 mechanismsH1 Defensive Culturei Material
The prevailing culture inhibits the behaviours required for effective transformation, including collaboration, challenge, experimentation, transparency and learning from failure.
Hypothesis. Risk increases when organisational culture inhibits collaboration, challenge, experimentation or the open identification of problems and mistakes.
H2 Leadership Vacuumi High
Leaders are managing, not leading. Absorbed in operational delivery, they stop providing direction, judgement and intervention.
Hypothesis. Risk increases when those responsible for leading the transformation become overly focused on operational management at the expense of strategic leadership.
H3 Strategic Ambiguityi High
The intended strategy and direction, priorities, scope or desired outcomes of the transformation are not clear enough or are interpreted inconsistently.
Hypothesis. Risk increases when ambiguity in strategy and direction, priorities, scope or desired outcomes causes inconsistent interpretation across the organisation.
H4 Communication Failurei High
Information does not move around the transformation with enough accuracy, relevance, speed or selectivity.
Hypothesis. Risk increases when communication is excessive, poorly targeted, distorted or too thin.
H5 Skills and Experiencei High
Whether the transformation has the required number, mix and levels of skills and experience in the geographic locations where they are needed.
Hypothesis. Risk increases when the organisation does not have the right number, the right mix or the right levels of skills and experience in the right geographic locations to execute the transformation.
H6 Incentive Misalignmenti Emerging
Individuals, teams or functions are rewarded or assessed against objectives that conflict with transformation outcomes.
Hypothesis. Risk increases when incentives and objectives encourage local optimisation at the expense of transformation outcomes.
Organisational
4 mechanismsO1 Structural Drag*i High
Organisational boundaries and structures create friction across the paths required to execute the transformation.
Hypothesis. Risk increases when organisational structures create barriers to the cross-functional collaboration required to execute the transformation.
O2 Accountability Vacuumi High
Responsibility and decision authority are so distributed that ownership becomes ambiguous, and decisions become contradictory or slow.
Hypothesis. Risk increases when accountability and decision authority fragment across multiple individuals, functions or governance bodies.
O3 Sponsorship Vacuumi Very high
The transformation has no sponsor senior, visible or active enough to remove barriers.
Hypothesis. Risk increases when senior executive sponsorship is not visible, authoritative or active enough to remove organisational barriers and maintain strategic alignment.
O4 Organisational Readinessi Very high
The ability and preparedness of the wider organisation both to participate in the transformation and to absorb its outputs successfully.
Hypothesis. Risk increases when the demands of the proposed change materially exceed the parent organisation's readiness to undertake or absorb it.
Delivery
7 mechanismsD1 Scope Breadthi Exposure, not failure Very high
The number of distinct organisational areas, functions, processes, systems, stakeholder groups or capabilities materially affected by the transformation.
Hypothesis. Risk increases when more organisational areas are materially affected.
D2 Scope Depthi Exposure, not failure High
The degree of fundamental change demanded within the areas affected by the transformation.
Hypothesis. Risk increases when the change demanded within affected organisational areas becomes more fundamental.
D3 Concurrency and Dependency Overloadi High
Too many mutually dependent transformation activities are being executed simultaneously for the available coordination capacity.
Hypothesis. Risk increases disproportionately when concurrency and interdependency outrun the organisation's ability to coordinate them.
D4 Validation Lagi Material
The elapsed time between making a material transformation assumption and obtaining credible evidence about whether it is correct.
Hypothesis. Risk increases when more time passes between making material assumptions and validating them.
D5 Strategic Response Lagi Very high
The elapsed time between credible evidence emerging and the transformation changing its strategy, roadmap or actions in response.
Hypothesis. Risk increases when more time passes between material new evidence emerging and the response to it.
D6 Heavyweight Governance Dragi High
Governance costs more in delay and delivery capacity than the control it buys.
Hypothesis. Risk increases when the cost, delay and delivery capacity consumed by governance exceed the risk reduction and control it provides.
D7 Integration Failurei High
Delivered transformation outputs cannot be successfully adopted, operated or incorporated by the wider organisation.
Hypothesis. Risk increases when insufficient attention is paid to how successful transformation outputs will be integrated into and absorbed by the parent organisation.
* One or more of this mechanism's questions were answered "Not enough evidence to answer". D1 Scope Breadth and D2 Scope Depth measure load exposure, not failure: both pre-registered success cases in the research base carried extreme values of each.
Next steps
Turn this reading into a plan.
What this does and does not claim
Learn more: the model | research paper and contact